Despite women making up half the population, women’s health has remained an enigma.
This is especially evident in the case of maternal mental health, which has been brought to the limelight with the Lindsey Clancy trial.
There’s a stigma surrounding postpartum depression, anxiety and psychosis. The stigma is worsened by the lack of awareness around the topic.
What can be done to improve the treatment of post-partum mental health disorders?
Join us for a discussion about mental health with women’s health experts on this hour of All Sides.
Guests:
- Tonya Fulwider, executive director, Mental Health America of Ohio
- Nicole Hollingshead, clinical psychologist in women’s behavioral health, Ohio State Wexner Medical Center
- Dr. Casia Horseman, psychiatrist, Ohio State Wexner Medical Center
Transcript
This transcript is generated with AI. To ensure its accuracy, review the audio file.
Amy Juravich: Welcome to All Sides with Amy Juravich. Former labor and delivery nurse Lindsay Clancy was back in court recently. This comes after a judge ruled a mistrial on whether she should be criminally responsible for murdering her three children. Prior to the deaths of her three children, Clancy reported staying up all night, writing in her journal she was having horrible thoughts and telling her immediate family something was wrong. Clancy had been medicated for postpartum mental health disorders, yet the medications didn't work. Unfortunately, maternal mental health is a mystery to most. The lack of information on the topic is causing people to wonder, could this have been prevented? Is Clancy innocent? How can this be stopped from ever happening again? We're talking about maternal mental this hour, and we have three experts joining us to help us understand the issues and hopefully break the stigma, at least a little bit. And first we have Tonya Fulwider, Executive Director of Mental Health America of Ohio. Welcome to the show, Tonya.
Tonya Fulwider: Thank you. Good morning.
Juravich: And we have Nicole Hollingshead, clinical psychologist in women's behavioral health at the OSU Wexner Medical Center. Welcome, Nicole.
Nicole Hollingshead: Thank you.
Juravich: And we also have Dr. Casia Horseman, a psychiatrist at the OSU Wexner Medical Center. Welcome Dr. Horseman. Thanks. All right, so we will get to the Clancy case a little bit later. I wanted to start though with some backgrounds and definitions, give our listeners an overview of what we're talking about today. So can you give an overview of maternal mental health disorders? Now I know that's a very big broad question, but maybe let's start with what can happen During or after pregnancy when it comes to a woman's mental health and anyone can start. All right, doctor, yeah, Casia, go ahead.
Dr. Casia Horseman: So, women are particularly vulnerable to either onset or worsening of mental health disorders, both during pregnancy and in the postpartum period. Throughout a woman's life, the times where they're most vulnerable to mental health disorder, either worsening or presenting, are during periods of rapid hormonal change. So puberty, pregnancy postpartums, menopause and then in between like every month when they have their period. So women can go into pregnancy with a history of a mental illness and those symptoms can potentially worsen during the pregnancy. They can get better during the pregnancies. It depends on a number of factors. Postpartum period when hormones are changing rapidly. And then there's all the other factors, the stress of a newborn, the lack of sleep. You can see an increase in symptoms of depression, bipolar disorder, anxiety, OCD. And for some women, this is the first time.
Juravich: They experience those symptoms. Oh, and Nicole, tell me a little bit more about the symptoms, because a lot of people years ago would call it the baby blues. I haven't heard that as much anymore, but it's still something some people say, where a woman just gets sad or feels different after having a baby. I don't know how you feel about the term baby blues, but yeah.
Hollingshead: Yeah, the baby blues still is a common phenomenon that occurs usually in those first two weeks during the postpartum period. So I describe it as, you know, one day you're happy and then moments later you might feel sad and then happy again. So within the baby Blues, we would still see somebody experiencing happiness and it usually is driven more by the hormone dysregulation that Dr. Horseman commented on. But when somebody is experiencing depression, is when they really do feel down and sad and have a real lack of motivation for days. So generally, we describe depression as for at least most days in a week or two, you really do that sadness and that down mood without those periods of happiness or joy. And that's when we would be concerned that you're experiencing more of an onset of maybe postpartum depression. And that can occur for those first few weeks. It can occur during pregnancy or up to a year.
Juravich: Year postpartum. And Tanya, can you talk about how common it is to experience it? Does it happen to every woman or we don't know, do we know how many women it happens to?
Fulwider: Yeah, well, something like the baby blues, incredibly common. But like Nicole said, that's something that's going to resolve on its own. But one in four to five women are going to experience a diagnosable mental health condition in the pregnancy or postpartum. And for some populations, black women, other women that are experiencing barriers, those rates are higher. And unfortunately, we see higher rates and oftentimes lack of access to care. And you know, I think what we hear most often is not I'm feeling symptoms of depression or I'm feelings symptoms of anxiety. It's something's not right. Something doesn't feel right with me. Or it's the things that sometimes people are more comfortable talking about. I'm just not getting enough sleep or, you know. So it's so important that when we hear those things that maybe aren't identifying a symptom. But someone's willing to say that our response is so important, whether it's family member or provider, that we're asking more questions and being able to dig into that.
Juravich: We'll get to those responses in a minute, but Cassia, I wanted to ask you about what you mentioned before, a person being more predisposed to have this happen to them if they had a mental health issue at some other point in their life. Is it more likely that it'll happen to you after having a baby if it happened before?
Horseman: Yes. One of the biggest risk factors for postpartum depression, postpartium anxiety, is a pre-existing depressive disorder or anxiety disorder. Even if it is well controlled during pregnancy, there is still a higher risk in the postpartumn period that those symptoms can or worsen.
Juravich: And Nicole, dig in a little bit more to what you said about how it can occur up to a year after having the baby. Because that's something that probably most people don't know. You would think it would happen right away when you're sleep deprived. I mean, after the baby is like four or five months old, don't you have it all figured out? Yeah, I think that's definitely one of the things.
Hollingshead: One of the myths around perinatal mood and anxiety disorders is that it just shows up right away and that it's very clear what this is. And I think the hard part in understanding perinatal mood and anxiety disorder is that most women are so motivated. You don't see it just by looking at them. They're usually very busy taking care of the child, taking care the house, taking care other family members. So the idea that depression looks like somebody who's just laying in bed crying all the time. Is generally not the case with our population. And so it can occur after several weeks, especially if you're having a baby that's having a hard time sleeping and you're not getting support at night, that sleep deprivation can really add up over the course of weeks and months and we can see it pop up months later. Maybe with the idea that I should be having it all together now, I should able to figure this out. Why is it so hard? And that can just exactly.
Juravich: A person's depressed mood. This is All Sides on 89.7 NPR News. We're talking about maternal mental health with Tanya Fulwider, Executive Director of Mental Health America of Ohio. Nicole Hollingshead, clinical psychologist in women's behavioral health at the OSU Wexner Medical Center. And Dr. Cassia Horsman, a psychiatrist at the Osu Wexler Medical Center and Dr. Horsmen, we're talking about a lot of different things here. We keep saying depression, anxiety. There's psychosis, right? These are all distinct different things. I mean, can you have depression and anxiety and psychosis is separate? Can you talk to me about the terms a little bit?
Horseman: Yeah, so depression, we talk about it as a diagnosis, but depressed mood can actually occur with bipolar disorder, with major depressive disorder. Anxiety, again, is a symptom that can occur in obsessive-compulsive disorder and generalized anxiety disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder. Um, psychosis is, again, a set of symptoms in a state that a person can get into at the extreme. Usually it's more associated with depression or like a major depressive disorder or a bipolar disorder than an anxiety disorder. Sometimes it can be hard to tell the difference though between severe OCD symptoms and psychotic symptoms.
Juravich: Okay, so we're getting into OCD there, and also on my list here, there's mania. I mean, there are a lot of different terms here. Do you have to be diagnosed with one of those? We shouldn't be self-diagnosing which one is going on, right?
Horseman: Yeah, for some women, the first time they present to psychiatric treatment is postpartum psychosis. Now, I wanna say it's very rare. Postpartum Psychosis, we are hearing about it a lot right now, but it is actually a very rare complication of pregnancy. But when it does occur, it's a medical emergency because people don't, they don't have impulse control, they're not necessarily entirely in touch with their reality. They can be dangerous potentially to themeselves and others. But a lot of times, postpartum is when things, and I guess the other part is that postpartium psychosis is probably most associated with bipolar disorder. And for a lot folks, they kind of consider it, if I see somebody with postpartrum psychosis, they have bipolar disorder until proven otherwise. And there are a number of women who that is their first time having any symptoms of bipolar disorder. Oh wow, okay.
Juravich: Tanya, many mothers experience intrusive thoughts. That's a phrase that we're hearing more so lately, intrus of thoughts. Can you tell me what those are? Like, what does it mean when I say intrusives thoughts and why do they manifest after pregnancy?
Fulwider: Yeah, well, there's a spectrum of that. So many, without a disorder, will experience an occasional frightening, scary thought. So an intrusive thought, something that pops into your head without warning, and it might be, what if I drop the baby down the stairs? Right, popped into your had without warning. That can happen, and I'm sitting next to the expert, so I won't go too far into this, but that can happen with a diagnosis like obsessive-compulsive disorder or not, right? So I know we've heard about the book "Good Moms Have Scary Thoughts" in this trial coverage. That's because those kinds of thoughts can pop into many mothers' heads. But then when we get into something like obsessative-compulsive disorder, which is connected often to those intrusive thoughts, and they are really debilitating. And then we have women who are afraid sometimes to share that because they think, what if I do it? What if I have psychosis, right? What if do hurt the baby? And the difference, right, is that They're horrified of those thoughts, where what Dr. Horsman was talking about with psychosis that break from reality with the intrusive thoughts associated with obsessive-compulsive disorder, OCD. They're afraid of those thought, but then were concerned about, are they willing to share that they're having these scary thoughts and able to get treatment.
Hollingshead: Yeah, Nicole, do you want to add about intrusive thoughts? Yeah, speaking off of what Tanya was mentioning, they are very common. So they've done studies in just normal everyday population that 95% of people have intrusives thoughts, right? And I always joke that- Men too? Men too, everybody. Just general population. Just add in the boys in here, okay? Absolutely, yeah. So if you've ever been behind a tractor trailer that's carrying logs of wood or several cars on it and you thought- What if those pop off and hit me? That's an intrusive thought, right? So everybody has those. It's just that in the postpartum period, we tend to have those about the things that we're worried about the most. And that's usually the baby's safety, right. So I always share an experience of an introsive thought I had in the postpartum where I was carrying my son. He was only several weeks old in the middle of the night trying to get him to South Soothe. And I noticed the stairs and I pictured us falling down the stairs, right? That's an intrusive thought. And that's okay, right. My reaction to that was, okay, I need to watch out for those stairs, right? I'm tired. As opposed to when somebody has OCD, they might think, why did I have this thought? Do I want to fall down the stairs? Am I not fit to be a good mom? Should I avoid taking care of the baby? And that's when they can start to develop these thoughts that I'm unfit or the baby's not safe with me and then start to rely on maybe some compulsive behaviors like I am avoiding taking care of the baby or I'm checking on the baby multiple times, I'm refusing to clean around the baby because I'm worried that something terrible can happen as I'm cleaning. Those are the things that you would really want to talk to your doctor if you're having these frequently. And starting to engage in maybe some weird behaviors because you're so scared about reacting to those thoughts.
Juravich: My main intrusive thought with both of my kids involved a blanket in the bed. And there was no blanket in bed, but I was just, I would wake up and the baby would actually be asleep, right? And you should be sleeping, but I would awake up because I was sure that the baby wasn't breathing, right, yeah. And it happened with both my kids. But anyway, we're not gonna make this about me. Dr. Horseman, I mean, when do you need, if everybody has them, if 95% of the population has them. When do we need to talk to someone about the intrusive thoughts?
Horseman: Well, I agree with Nicole. What I usually tell my patients is, to some degree, these thoughts are kind of adaptive. You have this small thing that you are given, keep this alive, which is, in and of itself, kind of a terrifying situation. And so worrying about, is my baby warm enough? Is my baby too warm? Is my Baby breathing? Is there a blanket in the bed? Is... Normal, that's what you do, and it helps, like having those thoughts top of mind helps you make sure that you're taking good care of your baby. It's when you can't reassure yourself, so if you have that thought, you check on the baby, the room is a good temperature, baby is sleeping and breathing, there's no blanket in the bed. A blanket didn't spontaneously appear out of nowhere. Exactly. And okay, if you are then able to be reassured, and you can then go about you know, taking a nap or doing some self-care, doing something else, then probably not something to be worried about. If you then leave and think, well, what if I accidentally knocked a blanket in the bed? Or, well, if I just didn't notice, maybe I better go count the breaths. And you can't reassure yourself that things are safe, this is okay, and it is keeping you from being able to sleep. Being able to take care of yourself, being able, for large numbers of people, they have other children, being able take care your other kids, then that's when it's starting to become problematic and probably should be checking with somebody about what kind of help you.
Juravich: We are talking about maternal mental health with a panel of experts this hour. And coming up, we are going to talk about what happens when maternal mental health becomes national news. That is when All Sides continues on 89.7 NPR News.
You're listening to All Sides, I'm your host Amy Juravich. Despite women making up half the population, women's health has remained an enigma. This is especially evident when it comes to the cases of maternal mental health, which has been brought to the limelight with the Lindsay Clancy trial. There is a stigma surrounding postpartum depression, anxiety, and psychosis. The stigma is worsened by a lack of awareness around the topic. We are talking about maternal mental health today and we will discuss what can be done to improve the treatment of postpartum mental health disorders. We have a panel of experts with us and we have Nicole Hollingshead, clinical psychologist in women's behavioral health at the OSU Wexner Medical Center. Thanks for being here, Nicole. Thank you. And we have Dr. Cassia Horsman, a psychiatrist at the Osu Wexler Medical Center, thanks for being Dr. Horsmen.
Hollingshead: No problem.
Juravich: And we also have Tanya Fullwider, executive director at Mental Health America of Ohio. Welcome, thanks for being here, Tanya. Thanks, Amy. All right, so in the case that has been making a lot of national news, it's the case of Lindsay Clancy, a 36-year-old former labor and delivery nurse accused of strangling her three young children. And the court case ended in a mistrial. Clancy's attorney says that she reached out to many people because she noticed that she was thinking and feeling unusual things. Are people with maternal mental health problems a threat to their children? Or is the Clancy case just extremely rare? Dr. Horstman, can we start with you? Is someone who has a mental health problem postpartum a threat their children.
Horseman: Generally, no. Most women are earnestly wanting to take care of their children if they worry that they might hurt their children, they take the steps to make sure everybody is safe. Usually the biggest risk that postpartum mental health disorders pose is that mom is not as involved in the children because either she's too afraid to because of intrusive thoughts. Or she's just not able to do it because of her level of depression. But postpartum psychosis is a very rare complication. And even, we do consider it a medical emergency because of the risk, but even for folks who are diagnosed with postpartrum psychosis, the vast majority of those do not hurt their children.
Juravich: All right, I wanted to get all three of you to just react to the amount of attention the Lindsay Clancy case has been receiving. I mean, it is Matt National News, everyone's talking about it. Nicole, can we start with you? What do you make of all this attention about this particular case of maternal mental health?
Hollingshead: Yeah, you know, I think it's obviously very sensationalized. It's a very terrible situation that happened. And so it is getting that amount of attention. But unfortunately, I Think too many people are worrying and sort of fueling their anxiety about what if I'm at risk, what if that was me. And as Dr. Horstman said, it is so rare. Postpartum psychosis is rare in one of every 1,000 births, Which, um, isn't nothing. You also wanna be thinking about your own individual risk factors. If you've experienced psychosis before, if you've experience a bipolar manic episode before, those can increase a person's risk, but even that's not a guarantee. So, working with a provider early on in your pregnancy, if you have those mental health diagnoses or you've had those risk factors before, to get you connected with care early and being able to establish with someone can really help to manage that anxiety. I think too often I'm hearing a lot of my patients coming in saying, oh, I'm following the Clancy case really closely, I am reading a lot about it and that is just adding to their anxiety and it's usually not helpful. And so we really don't want people to sort of take this and say, now I feel like I'm at risk so I'm doing things like avoiding taking care of the baby or I'm not trusting in myself because that's gonna lead to complications.
Juravich: Tanya, what about you? What do you make of all the attention this particular case has been receiving?
Fulwider: Well, I think I second what the other guests have said, which is it scares women to hear so much about this case and see what happened, the tragedy that happened, and think, could I do that? What if I do? What if? What if is something you hear all the time from perinatal women? What if this? What if that? And so... You know, as they've said, this is not common. You know, psychotic spectrum disorders are not common where depression, anxiety, scary thoughts are incredibly common. And so women are connecting, you know something that they're hearing about all the time with their own experience. And then, you now, if you have family members that maybe don't, most people don't know the difference between you know, what is a delusion and what is an intrusive thought, right? I mean, you heard it described in coverage all the time. And so it's important that we have access to specialists that, you know can can help sort it out. But, you know, and I think also it's it scares women because they hear in the coverage about how many providers. Lindsay Clancy did connect with, and many people are saying, I don't have that access. I'm afraid, because I don't have that kind of access to care. And so what does that mean for me and my recovery and my options for being taken care of?
Juravich: We'll talk about that access to care in a little bit, but Dr. Horsman, I want to have you weigh in on just what you make of the national attention and how women are taking it in.
Horseman: Well, obviously, as everybody has said, it was a horrible tragedy, and that is certainly a reason that it got a large amount of attention. I think it does resonate with women because I think there are a lot of women out there who have had difficulties in the postpartum period, not to the extent of postpartium psychosis and things like that, but that probably were not, either they weren't able to articulate. Or we're too afraid to articulate. And so I think that's probably why a lot of women pay a lot attention to this, because in a way, this is kind of a representative of women who are having postpartum mental health complications.
Juravich: The biggest extreme worry that they have, yeah. Yeah. Let's talk about the partners in this situation. The Lindsay Clancy case is an extreme example, but her husband, Patrick Clancy, said this in an interview that he gave to CBS News in "60 Minutes."
Patrick Clancy: Did you know anything about postpartum mental illness before this experience started? No. I could piece together what it was like to be really, really anxious or depressed, but I didn't know how to manage a postpartal illness. I think mental illness has this ability to be tragically deceptive, so I'm sure there are things that I didn't see.
Juravich: Now we're not going to litigate Patrick Clancy at all on this show, but I wanna talk about the partner's role in noticing what's going on with the mother. Nicole, can we start with you on that? What is the partner role in the noticing?
Hollingshead: Yeah, I think just being aware and really checking in with mom. After you have a baby, everybody's so focused on the baby. How's the baby doing? I want to hold the baby, and talking all about that. I think it's really important for the partner to be the advocate for mom. How are you doing? How are feeling? And being able to sit down and ask those questions and observe if she's avoiding taking care of the baby or notice if. She hasn't showered in a few days, you know, and really encouraging that level of support. I often hear patients, especially if the partner doesn't get any paid parental leave and goes right back to work, say, well, now I have to be the one who's getting up with a baby every night because my partner's working, to which I usually remind the women that you're working a full-time job, right, with no breaks. It's 24-7. So the partner making sure that you were figuring out. How can I help get up with the baby in the middle of the night? What can be my role to get you as much sleep as possible, even though we're both.
Juravich: Working full-time. What about, Dr. Horstman, what about what was said in that clip related to, I don't even know if I want to use the word hiding, but what if women are really at hiding their symptoms, saying everything is fine.
Horseman: Yeah, that can be really difficult because a lot of women are going to try to do it all. And again, I think the important part of discussing the role of the partner is remembering that they are a partner. And so how do I take things off your plate? We are partners in this and there are certain things that you have to do if mom is breastfeeding. Dad can't really, or the other partner can't really do a lot with that. If mom is breastfeeding, then they're the ones who are getting up with the baby in the middle of the night, but the partner can help with, not even help, but take ownership of taking care of the other children, taking care of diaper changes. And again, like Nicole was saying, checking in. A lot of times with my patients that are getting close to their due date, we will have an appointment with the partner where we talk about, particularly for women who have a bipolar diagnosis, what are we going to do to help guard the sleep? Because for a lot of women with bipolar disorder, sleep dysregulation can be one of the bigger triggers to having worse like mania or worsening depression. And we discuss things like... You know, your job in the postpartum period is to take care of yourself, take care of your baby, and for the two of you to get to know each other. It's not necessarily to do the laundry, it's not necessary to wash the dishes, and everybody probably needs to be okay with, at least for a little while, letting things kind of go, because you're both figuring all of these things out, how to be parents together, and how you're gonna manage your lives going forward. And this is a very intensive period of taking care of this little one that's not gonna last forever. So it's okay if the house is a little bit less clean. So kind of working with both patients but also their partners on being okay with things not being exactly as they were before the baby was born, because they're not gonna be. And figuring out how to support and give everybody.
Juravich: Permission. Tanya, what would you like to add about the partner's role in the situation with noticing what's going on with the mother?
Fulwider: Yeah, I mean, I think looking at the partner and the support system as a whole, how can any loved one pay attention to mom? Who's in her circle that can support her? So whether it's a partner, whether it' neighbors, grandparents, but thinking about, and as early as possible, it's really dreamy when you can have those conversations during pregnancy. And particularly, at least in our groups, is trying to think about putting the list on the fridge during pregnancy because sometimes, especially in those early postpartum weeks, you know, everybody's tired. It's a totally new reality, a 24-hour reality, and it's hard to even think, wait a minute, what should I be doing? I have no idea. I don't barely remember my name, let alone. Whether the trash needs to go out or a load of laundry. So the more you can think about things during pregnancy, right, and get ahead, or even in just the more peaceful moments, if baby is sleeping to have those conversations, all right, let's plan and think about what needs to be done during those moments rather than in the chaotic moments where baby's crying and then everybody's upset because we don't know what to do and I don't have any help and so.
Juravich: We are talking about maternal mental health with a panel of experts this hour. With us, we have Tanya Fullwider from Mental Health America of Ohio, and we have Nicole Hollingshead and Dr. Cassia Horsman, both from the OSU Wexner Medical Center. How can partners show more support? So we were just talking about like the noticing, the helping, it's not even helping but being a true partner, right? But then is there anything else that someone should, that a partner should do? Cause I'm thinking more along the lines of having the conversation of maybe you need to talk to someone else. Yeah, can we, Nicole, can you get, talk to us about that leap whenever you, when does the partner notice and say, This is beyond what I can help with.
Hollingshead: Yeah, you know, again, kind of going back to that idea of the baby blues, if you're noticing mom is crying a lot in those first couple of weeks, but able to feel happy, then I wouldn't raise any red flags at that point. But if that's extending for several weeks and months and mom's, you know, crying or one of the sneakier symptoms of especially anxiety is irritability. So if mom is really short, and it's usually short at dad, or the partner, because or closest. And you feel like she's just snipping at everybody, she has no patience, that can actually be a really clear symptom of anxiety and feeling really overwhelmed. And so if you're noticing mom's just not acting like herself and maybe searching, you know, what are my resources? You know, where can I turn to for support and help maybe point her in the right direction? If she's seen a therapist or a counselor before, you know calling to see if we can get another appointment. And especially starting with the OB, if you don't know where to go, calling the OB's office and saying, can we do a mood check? Cause I'm really concerned about her.
Juravich: I feel like the Clancy case, even though it's extreme, has increased stigma. There's all kinds of opinions everywhere. Dr. Horsman, do you find that sometimes women don't want to say anything about their intrusive thoughts or how they're feeling because they're worried that someone's gonna take their children away from them? Absolutely.
Horseman: I've had any number of patients who will say, I don't wanna tell you what I'm thinking. And usually I give them as extreme of a thought as I have ever heard, which I will not say on this, but basically to say, you can tell me anything and I am going to, we are gonna talk through this and figure out how to help you. And for most patients, I have actually had patients come to me who have had children in the past and say, yes, with my last pregnancy, I had postpartum psychosis. And it was because this person had thoughts about, you know, what if I kill my baby? But when we talked it through, it wasn't psychosis, it was these OCD intrusive thoughts and being able to explain to somebody that even if you have these thoughts, If they are horrifying to you, if you are doing everything you can to make sure that this child is going to be safe, then that is not psychosis. And you're not actually a danger to your child. So just because you have the thoughts, telling somebody does not mean that your child will be taken away from you. Now, you know. The folks that we have more concerns about or the folks who think that there's a complete logical reason for those thoughts, a lot of times those can be harder to elicit from a patient and we are looking at other symptoms of psychosis that are kind of helping us with that diagnosis.
Juravich: Is there an instance when you're, I don't know if you're a mandatory reporter, like do you have to tell the partner or like, I dunno, who do you tell? If it like, like you, you, it's supposed to be a private conversation with a psychologist or a psychiatrist, right? So, yeah. Well, we are all mandated reporters.
Horseman: So, if there is something where we are concerned that there is a danger to either the patient, if they're saying they're suicidal and they've got a plan, or the child, then we will take steps to probably hospitalize that patient. Usually if they are having intrusive thoughts that are not dangerous, one of the things that I will encourage is... You know, let's get your support system involved here. Mental health can get worse in the darkness. If you are hiding things, it's kind of like mold. It'll get worse. If you shine a bright light on it, it's a lot easier to take care of it. And so pulling in the partner, the parents, whoever they have as their support system so that they are aware, this is what this person is struggling with, can be a really important way to help them get through it. And for the people around them to be a little more vigilant about what am I seeing something different from what we've already.
Juravich: Talked about. This is All Sides on 89.7 NPR News. I'm your host Amy Juravich and we have a panel of women's mental health experts staying with us. Coming up we're going to talk about ways to get help and what the medical community can do to improve women's health care. That's when All Sighs continues on 89. 7 NPR news.
You're listening to All Sides, I'm your host Amy Juravich. Just because a mom experiences a maternal mental health disorder, it doesn't make her a bad mom. There are a myriad of factors that contribute to mental health issues during and after pregnancy, and no mother is alone in her struggles. How can these disorders be screened and treated, and how can lack of access worsen symptoms? Still with us, we have a panel of experts on the topic of maternal mental health. We have Dr. Cassia Horsman, psychiatrist at the OSU Wexner Medical Center. Thanks for being here. Thank you. And we have Nicole Hollingshead, clinical psychologist in women's behavioral health at the Osu Wexler Medical Center, thanks Nicole.
Hollingshead: Happy to be here.
Juravich: And also with us, we have Tanya Fullwider, Executive Director of Mental Health America of Ohio. Thanks, Tanya. Thank you. All right, so I would like to discuss further what treatment looks like, mothers experiencing symptoms. Dr. Horsman, you're a psychiatrist, so you can prescribe drugs to help. Are there drugs treatments available that help?
Horseman: Yes, there are. There's any number of medications that are helpful for depression, for mood stabilization and bipolar disorder. There has recently been a medication that is specific for postpartum depression. And so, and many of these medications are considered to be safe in breastfeeding. Okay.
Juravich: Okay, and so, do we always need the medication, or I- Nicole, I guess I'll go to you, is choc therapy, is it both, like, does everyone always need medication or sometimes is chock therapy enough?
Hollingshead: Yeah, you know, it's really individualized, right? So if somebody has had a medication that has worked for previous mental health issues, depression or anxiety in the past, you know they wanna work with their OB or a psychiatrist on staying on that medication if it's appropriate and there's research to support that it is safe to use during pregnancy or during lactation. Some people, if this is their first episode, they might want to start with therapy or maybe they want to just focus on. Their mental health has been stable in the past, so they really want to just start with therapy. We, on the therapy side of things, certainly do not discourage any medication. Some people really do need both. And we know that, for some people, both is the most effective. So it's really important to have that conversation and think about what is really going to help me most of all. Maybe it is just doing a course of In my clinic, we do cognitive behavioral therapy, doing eight to 12 sessions to really help you to feel better. And that does the trick. Or if you're depression, your anxiety is so severe that you can't even engage in the therapy process. You can't do some of the homework assignments that are given. That's when we would consider a medication to help alleviate some of those symptoms.
Juravich: And Tanya, what about this idea of making an appointment for therapy or even to see a psychiatrist too? I know wait lists can be deep. What if you need the therapist now, like tomorrow? You can't wait four to six weeks, eight weeks for whenever you call and your in-network provider says they have an appointment.
Fulwider: Right, yeah. Well, a couple of things. I mean, one, just I'll add that the most important treatment is the one that someone has access to and they're willing to do, whatever that is, right? So that's, but then as you're asking about access, yeah, one of the things that our program does is work directly with frontline providers, OBs, pediatricians, and they'll refer to our team of peers, so certified peer supporters. And they will talk to mom within 24 business hours. So they're having a conversation with another woman who's experienced a mental health complication, has recovered, and provides that immediate support, and then helps mom find whether it is a therapist, a psychiatrist, or another treatment that they have access to, and provides them support along the way. So whether first appointment is a couple weeks away, but they have access to support right away. And...
Juravich: How does a woman know that that exists? Does a hospital tell you after you have a baby, do they hand you a pamphlet and say, this is who you called to get help right away? Well.
Fulwider: What we hope at our program is that the hospital, the OBs, are actually sending our peer's mom's name and our peers call her. We don't even want to ask her to pick up the phone because we know that particularly when you're depressed or anxious, just making that one phone call. And I mean, depression tells you you're alone and broken. And so even just making call can be hard. So we really want our health care system to provide that, we want OBs to screen, we want them to ask the questions, and then we want then to refer directly and have care providers reach out to her.
Juravich: Nicole and Cassia, is that happening? Are, like, are OBs doing this? And in our call, like do you know?
Hollingshead: Um, you know, here at OSU, I do see our OBs, you know, referring to poem, uh, that Tanya is mentioning here in, in central Ohio. Um, You know, so I do think it is happening a little bit more, but certainly not to the degree that we would want every hospital to know that these resources.
Juravich: Success tell me about tell me what poem is yeah it stands for something yeah Tanya poem
Fulwider: Yeah, it does. Perinatal Outreach and Encouragement for Moms. And the name really came about in the wake of the Andrea Yates case, which was another notable case around postpartum psychosis, when women we were working with in our support groups were so afraid to say the term postpartrum depression because they were so afraid. And so. And it's a peer. It's a program that's all peers. All women have experienced some sort of pregnancy postpartum mental health complication, have recovered and become certified, and then work directly with on the front end, OBs, pediatricians, hospitals, and then with our specialized clinical partners to refer to them and then provide that support around them. Peers don't replace the important specialized clinical treatment, but they're the connective tissue, we hope, in between that. It's been
Juravich: many years, a decade, since I had a baby. So I remember being in my OB's office for the check like six weeks after having the baby. And I know that there was a poster in the bathroom. I know I was given a pamphlet, but are we doing better now 10 years later, do you think? I think.
Fulwider: Like Nicole said, we've definitely made a lot of strides. There's a lot more conversation around perinatal mental health complications. We do have more providers that are referring, but is it universal? No, you're not gonna be guaranteed to get a direct referral. There are still plenty of providers that are handing out pamphlets and putting up posters and expecting women to figure out when they're not sleeping and breasts are leaking and all things are happening. To then also try to find a specialist bit.
Juravich: And and I'm not saying my doctor my doctor was amazing. I love her and I still do and I still see that practice. I'm I'm, not I'm downing the pamphlet. I was very well taken care of. I'm just saying that if a woman is really good at hiding it, you know, she'll take the pampha and say thank you, right? Yeah. So, Dr. Horseman, roughly half of the US women or families, roughly, half of US families struggle with diaper needs. You know, Having a baby is expensive. Talk to me about lack of access to professional treatment for postpartum issues. What if you can't afford it? Therapy is expensive. Nicole, either one of you can talk about this. I mean, lack of ac-
Horseman: access is a problem for mental health treatment in general, particularly in rural areas. There is a shortage of psychiatric providers. A lot of people, their psychiatric provider is their primary care doctor, if they have a primary care, which is another issue as well. There's a number of women who they're obese are sort of their mental health providers. So. Other specialties have kind of, like they do what they can. One of the things about the postpartum visit is a lot of women don't go to their postpartums check. And that's when I think a lot of the testing for postpartium depression is being done, a lot of the screens from the OB side. So I imagine there are a number of women that we miss because of that. Programs like Tanya's can. Really make a difference in that it can help get support and helps them have somebody who can sort of navigate the system. It's not an easy system. And find potentially sliding scale. We do have some free clinics, even psychiatry free clinics here in Columbus. So those resources are out there. It's a matter of being able to.
Juravich: Find them we are running short on time But I want to give you each a chance to answer this question before we run out of time So how would you like to see the stigma around maternal mental health issues reduced? Like what do you want people listening to to know Nicole about it and Getting you know moving past it
Hollingshead: Yeah, I think the biggest thing is that fear, that if I share something, then they'll think I'm an unfit mom, that they'll believe the scary thoughts that I'm having about myself, and knowing that it's okay to talk to people about these things, people maybe within your support network, a partner, a parent, a friend who has gone through the newborn phase before, and start by reaching out to your OB. Share with them what you're experiencing so that-
Juravich: that you can get that support that you need. Tanya, what about you? What do you want people listening to know about maternal mental health issues?
Fulwider: Well, they're the most common complication of pregnancy and childbirth. So many, many pregnant and new moms are experiencing these mental health conditions. And they are good moms. It is not you. And they are common. They're treatable. Recovery is possible. You're a good mom. And you have the ability to get you deserve good care. And you will feel better and be able to enjoy. Being a mom, yeah
Juravich: And Cassia, what do you want people to know?
Horseman: For the for women who are having these symptoms, you're not alone. There have been many women before you There will be many women after you there are women right now who are dealing with some of the same concerns and and symptoms that you are and so Speaking about it especially within families Can help reduce that stigma and help people you to find that support going forward because it It is hard in our medical system and so, you know, the more we are discussing it with other folks, the better.
Juravich: Find out about the resources out there. Okay, and within 30 seconds that we have left, Tanya, just remind our listeners how they can get the help that you mentioned through poem. Like, what do they need to do?
Fulwider: Well, our website is mhaohio.org, and all the resources are on there, and I hope their OBs will also send them our way.
Juravich: We have been talking about maternal mental health with Tonya Fulwider, executive director of Mental Health America of Ohio. Thank you so much for joining us, Tanya. Thank you. And Nicole Hollingshead, clinical psychologist in women's behavioral health at the OSU Wexner Medical Center. Thanks for your time today, Nicole. Thank you And Dr. Casia Horseman, psychiatrist at the OSU Wexler Medical Center, thank you for joining today, Dr. Horsman. Thank you for having me. And I want to say thank you to the All Sides staff, our producers Marcus Charleston and Erin Esmott Rabinowitz. Our student producers are Brianna Fortunate, Blake Anderson, and Jane Asante Tutu. Video production by the Ohio Channel, board operation by Chris Johnston and Trey Hayes. This is All Sides on 89.7 NPR News. I'm Amy Juravich. Thanks for joining us.