Columbus is a fashion powerhouse.
It’s home to major corporate brands, a test-market for retail innovation and has lots of emerging local designers. But what happens when clothing production gets out of hand?
A new docuseries called "Tangled Threads" examines the fashion industry and traces the decisions that have led to an overabundance of clothing in thrift stores and landfills.
We’ll speak with the local talent working on the series on this hour of All Sides.
Guests:
- Nicholas Breyfogle, professor and chair, Department of History, Ohio State University
- Lisa Goldsand, founder, Circular Thrift LLC
- Tasha Lewis, associate professor, Department of Human Sciences, Ohio State University
- Brett Langolf, executive producer/director, "Tangled Threads"
Transcript
This transcript is generated with AI. To ensure its accuracy, review the audio file.
Amy Juravich: Welcome to All Sides with Amy Juravich. From New England to the South, there was a time when textile mills in the United States were making a lot of the clothing that outfitted America. Times have changed, and like many other industries, most of the clothes we wear are made overseas. The three-part docu-series, "Tangled Threads," will explore the history, systems, and decisions shaping the clothing industry. And here is a part of the trailer for the documentary.
We are speaking with a local talent involved in making the docu-series "Tangled Threads" This Hour. And our conversation begins with the history of US fashion, which has led to an overabundance of discarded clothes in both our thrift stores and our landfills. To get the conversation started, we have Nicholas Breyfogle, professor and chair of the Ohio State Department of History. Welcome to the show, Nicholas.
Nicholas Breyfogle: Thanks so much for having me today.
Juravich: So since we're talking about fashion, who are you wearing? What are you?
Breyfogle: It's the question we ask everybody that we interview on the film, but I am wearing Patagonia.
Juravich: Okay.
Breyfogle: And a little bit of Eddie Bauer. Okay, we'll talk about you. Lots of cotton.
Juravich: OK, lots of cotton. We'll talk about Patagonia later in the hour. But yeah, so as a historian from textile mills to commercial manufacturing, how did clothing production in the United States evolve? Like how how big was clothing manufacturing back in the day?
Breyfogle: So, to answer your big question, in some ways, the history of clothing manufacturing in the U.S. And around the world goes through three big stages, beginning first with the Industrial Revolution and the way in which cotton was at the core of that process. The second being the shift towards human-made fibers that comes in in the 20th century, and then the third being changes in terms of how how we produce and market and sell clothing, what we call the fast fashion process that comes in starting really in the 1980s. So we have these three different moments that are really important in this whole process. I'd love to dive into them if that's okay. Yeah.
Juravich: Yeah, well, yeah, so so tell me about, you know, what what it means to to manufacture clothing in America. Yeah, I talked about that. Yeah.
Breyfogle: So it's important for us to realize the documentary that we're doing is really focused in many ways on environmental questions and the types of environmental impacts that the clothing has had and continues to have and the ways in which in some ways these environmental impacts, these health impacts on our bodies are getting worse and worse as we move through time. And so throughout human history, The production of clothing, whether it's an animal skin or fish skins or whatever, has some kind of environmental impact. But we see profound changes really beginning in the 18th, coming into the 19th centuries when we see the beginning of what we call the Industrial Revolution, where we start to bring fossil fuel power, particularly coal power, into production facilities, which then changes how we make our clothing in the United States and around the world. I mean, this process starts first. In Great Britain in the 18th and 19th century, and then the U.S. Comes pretty closely behind that.
Juravich: Yeah, I'm picturing more that it started as hand sewing a lot of clothes, or using sewing machines at least, and that kind of thing. And the clothes were made to be worn for a really long time, and they were made really well. And then I'm picture the transition into a machine making everything. Is that what happened? No, that's exa-
Breyfogle: No, that's exactly right. For most of human history, the clothing we made was exactly that. It was handmade. It was often made at home rather than in a factory. It tended to be made by families where different people in the family had different roles. So the father in the family might be the weaver. The wife or the children would spin cotton and this sort of thing. They would do it in their homes. Sometimes they would sell it on a market. Sometimes they were just used for themselves. But it's domestic, it's family-based, it' s hand-done, and then as we start to see more and more machines, things like the cotton gin or the power loom or the water loom and these sorts of things, when these start to be developed in the 18th century, then it makes less and less sense to do it in your house. It's pretty hard to have a massive weaving machine in your house, much easier to do it in a factory or in a centralized location. So we move, we see this huge shift in terms of how things are produced, who's doing the production, where they're doing it, just their whole working experience from domestic family base to being in a separate factory kind of setting where bosses can make you work nine to five or usually sort of five in the morning till eight at night type of thing. Rather than at home where you control your own kind of hours and this sort of thing. So a huge change that happens there in terms of the lived experience of the people who are making the goods, but also huge change in terms of how the whole process is powered. Because if it started mostly hand-based and human power, what we see is, as we move towards factories, initially they're water powered. You have water wheels that spin the various machines. And then, After 1784, with James Watt and the steam engine, they start to realize how they can use coal power to produce steam engines and steam power that then can power these factories and these machines. And that sets off an incredible explosion. You combine the power of the fossil fuels, the energy that they unleash, which was something unseen on the planet to that point. With cotton production, and we see an explosion in the number of factories, the amount of cotton that's being produced, and it really, really starts to take off, again, late 18th, early part of the 19th century. And, yeah.
Juravich: Yeah, and what industry can have ripple effects on many other businesses because they all depend on each other? Are there other businesses that are impacted by the textile industry too?
Breyfogle: I mean, everything, ultimately, from start to finish. When we think about, in the textile industry, so primarily it's cotton-based in the United States, and of course, where's the cotton coming from? It's coming from the South, it's coming particularly from slave economies and slave societies, and so when we think about, use the word businesses, but when we thing about how stuff is produced, then. The shift to these kinds of factories and the incredible demand that they had for raw material to make new cotton products meant an expansion, an acceleration of the way in which the slave system worked and the extraction of human labor in the South. So you have this huge transformation there makes the kind of white Southern plantation owners incredibly wealthy. And then, In the North, where you start to see many of these factories first being built, like in Lowell, Massachusetts, and this sort of thing, the people who run those factories become tremendously wealthy, then they then have funds that can invest in other sorts of areas. And clothing, you have people working who then have incomes who can start to purchase other sorts things. So the ripple effects throughout the whole economy are huge.
Juravich: So yeah, a huge part of the economy, ripple effects are huge, but you're mentioning the clothing industry as one of the oldest and dirtiest industries. I mean, I can picture why making plastic is bad for our environment, right? And we've done whole shows about the problems with plastic, but you don't think of clothes in that same way. I don't of clothes as being old, dirty manufacturing, but it is.
Breyfogle: Certainly how it started off and continues in different sorts of ways today. So in the time period that we're talking about, there's really, I mean, there's three big ways that we see clothing manufacturing as being sort of dirty in the word that, so that quote was from Vincent Stanley, who is the chief philosophy officer of Patagonia, that the one that starts off the little, the trailer. And it's a reminder to us of the ways in which clothing has. From its very beginning has had huge environmental impacts and continues to. But in the 18th and 19th century, part of it is you need water to make all of this happen. So they are building massive reservoirs, redirecting rivers in all sorts of different ways, which affects, it affects people's agricultural land, people's land gets drowned out, different species get affected. We also see pollution of water right from the very beginning because many clothes are dyed in a variety of different ways and even with natural dyes when you're dumping that waste and effluent into water systems to get to be rid of it. And the third way is that when you burn coal, it produces all sorts of air pollution.
Juravich: I wouldn't I yeah, I had no idea the coal was involved in making clothes at all.
Breyfogle: Yeah, I know. The coal initially is a revolution as a power source in terms of how much you can produce and where you can produce it because factories used to have to be near water. Now you can stick a factory anywhere because you have coal power. You shovel it into the engine. It burns and produces a massive amount of energy through steam power, which is incredible. So, you know, the impact there is in all of those areas, for example, is tremendous. The environmental impact then... Accelerates in many respects and becomes different when we get into the 20th century with the beginnings of our use of human-made fibers.
Juravich: This is All Sides on 89.7 NPR News. We're talking about the historical role of textiles in fashion, and we're talking with Nicholas Breyfogle, professor and chair of the Ohio State Department of History. Yeah, so thus far, we've mentioned cotton several times, and that was a crop of the South, key to clothing production. But what led to the creation of synthetic fibers? You know, polyester, rayon, nylon, that what I'm wearing is probably made out of, I'm sure, so.
Breyfogle: So in some ways, two things drove that. One was to try to find cheaper solutions and more accessible solutions to producing clothes for people. Because even with factory production, with cotton and this sort of thing, it still was expensive to buy clothes. And the percentage of your income that you would put into purchasing your clothing would be a lot more than we spend today. So there was a sort of search to find other ways to produce fibers clothing. And it led first to sort of plant-based or cellulose-based types of synthetic fibers, so acetate or rayon coming out of the late 19th century. And then we get into the early part of the 20th century where with the chemical industry, with the rise particularly of gasoline and other types of fossil fuels, we have new materials to build new types of chemical substances. And that's what really pushes this forward. It's a curious thing that things like nylon, polyester, spandex, which come out kind of from the late 1930s into the 1950s, they were initially seen as an incredible, again, a kind of revolution, because now you didn't have to rely on cotton all the time, which takes up vast amounts of fields and has difficult labor and all these sorts of things. And instead, you would have this cheap other type fiber like nylon was always considered well. Silk for everybody now. Now we have a replacement for silk, which is gonna be amazing. And in many respects, was considered environmentally friendly because they often used waste byproducts from petroleum production to make the chemicals, to make these new types of fibers. So it was taking a waste from another productive process and putting it to work for clothing production. They thought it would be great. Turns out not so much. Uh, and, uh... But that was the big push in that way.
Juravich: Well, it certainly made clothes cheaper. But how has the marketing, the price, the culture around clothing reshaped what we expect from clothes? Because I would think that, you know, talking about these three different eras you mentioned before, people expect different things out of their clothes.
Breyfogle: Very much so. I mean, the world we live in today, I'm sure, your kids, my kids, their clothing is part of their identity, it's part of the culture, it is part their social life. You go down to the mall, you buy new stuff, you have a sense of what is in fashion and what isn't, and that fashion changes quite drastically and quite quickly. And so you You have a culture where you have influences in social media telling you... What you should and shouldn't be wearing, and that changes on a regular basis. That's certainly not the case, or the experience of buying clothing 100 years ago, where, yeah, you would go into a store and, and as a man, for example, you might buy one suit, and this is the suit that you would have your whole life, and you would get married in it, you would got to whatever formal functions you had to do in it and then you would get buried in it at the end of the day, and so it was your suit. But it was supposed to last forever and ever and you did it once and you know, you try not to get fat, I guess at the end of the day, but So that the the way we consume and how we act as consumers is so totally different now from what it was even a hundred years ago And the same thing is happening on the production side I mean the people who are selling and marketing these are now marketing them in different sorts of ways and
Juravich: I don't think I've seen a marketing campaign for a suit for life. I know you don't see that anymore, it's for sure. Thrift shopping has grown in popularity in recent years, but it's also become a victim of its own success because now we're at the point where there's so much clothes and people have so many clothes everywhere and they, relatively speaking, don't cost that much. So you can just give them away whenever you don't t want them anymore to a thrift store. How do we get to the point were thrift stores are now having to turn away clothing donations due to an overabundance? I mean Would people 200 years ago be shocked that we had too much clothing?
Breyfogle: I mean, I think shocked is an understatement. I mean the world of abundance in which we live, and it's not just in clothing, but clothing is a clear example of that, is something unimaginable to most people. And honestly unimaginably, not just even 200 years ago, but even 50 years ago. The statistics tell us that over the last 15 years, we are now producing, consuming 60% more clothing than we were. So just. You know, in our lifetimes, we're seeing a massive increase in the amount of clothing that's being produced. And as a result, the kind of amount of potential waste that there is. And we're in that strange place where on average, right, an American citizen will wear a new piece of clothing seven times before they get rid of it. Just seven, on average.
Which is nothing, right? And it shows the rapidity of the changeover in which we're living at the moment. And thrift stores have been incredible that way because they offer that opportunity for reuse. So I wear it my 10 times, I can give it to the thrift store, somebody else gets their 10 and it goes on and it goes on. But it's a reflection of the fact that we produce so much clothing at the moments that, and for me that's one of the biggest problems. I mean, if we are. Thinking ahead and if we're thinking about, so what are solutions to all of these kinds of crises? The three Rs of reduce, reuse, recycle are our guides here and the first one always being reduced. Like we need to produce less, we need consume less, we actually don't need that much new clothing. And then yeah, reuse next and thrift stores being the way to go that way. And then if we can't do that, then please let's recycle before, rather than just throwing it into the garbage heap.
Juravich: We've been speaking about the history of fashion and clothes manufacturing with Nicholas Breyfogle, professor and chair of the Ohio State Department of History. Thank you for being here today.
Breyfogle: My pleasure. Thanks so much for having me.
Juravich: And coming up, we're going to talk about the true cost of what we wear. That's when All Sides continues on 89.7 NPR News.
You're listening to All Sides. I'm your host, Amy Juravich. The upcoming documentary series called "Tangled Threads" explores the history and environmental impact of the global fashion system. As home to fashion brands like Victoria's Secret, Abercrombie& Fitch, Express, and DSW, Columbus figures prominently in the global fashion system, we are unraveling clothing this hour and looking behind what we wear. Joining us now is Lisa Goldsand. Founder of Circular Thrift, a nonprofit that offers community-centered circular fashion and textile waste solutions. Welcome to All Sides, Lisa. Thank you so much. So glad to be here. And Tasha Lewis, associate professor in the Ohio State Department of Human Sciences. Welcome to All Sides, Tasha.
Tasha Lewis: Thank you. Glad to be here.
Juravich: So Tasha, there are a lot of places where fashion has been a footprint in our natural world. Do you think most consumers are aware of this?
Lewis: I don't think we think about it as consumers. So when we see a finished garment, we don't necessarily see the fibers that were used, the sheep that were shorn, or the polyester that was made in a factory. We just see a finish product. And so even when I teach my classes, and my class yesterday, in fact, the students and I looked at fiber content labels in garments, just to understand like, this garment is something you would wear for this, but look at the fiber content. Did that shock you? So just understanding there's a connection between our natural world and our clothing is not always evident, and sometimes until you look at the fiber content label in your clothing to really understand that, oh, somebody had to shear a sheep to make this, or somebody had to harvest some flax to make linen to make this, so not always a straight line unless the label or the hang tag tells you that information.
Juravich: Yeah, I mainly look at the label just to figure out if I can put something in the dryer or not. Exactly. But not really thinking about it. But I don't think beyond my own personal ability to put it in the drier, which is a bonus for a piece of clothing, you know? Well, anyway. And not everything should go in the dryers. Should go in dryers, right. I know. I know, line dry, man. But we're currently seeing from the government that they're easing regulations in many areas that affect our health and environment. And Tasha, from your perspective, do you have any concerns? Are there any regulations for the fashion industry, the clothing industry, and are things changing?
Lewis: Well, if we think about the clothing industry in the United States, we do not make a lot of the clothing that we wear here. Most of our clothing, close to like 98% is imported. So the regulations around clothing manufacture are older. A lot of things were made here, but they're not anymore. One of the historic examples I think of is a fiber call rayon that you might see in some of your garments. At one point it was manufactured in the US, even in some parts of Ohio. And because of the environmental regulations, people were getting sick near the factory. They actually banned its production. So we have a history of sort of regulating production a lot more, but we just don't make a lot of it here. So we don't have a lot of regulations that apply just because we don't make a lotta clothing here anymore.
Juravich: Lisa, bringing you into the conversation, according to your bio, you are exploring ways to support the advancement of the circular economy in textiles. So can you explain the circular economy to me?
Lisa Goldsand: Yeah, sure. So following up on what Professor Lewis said, we don't produce a lot of the clothing that we wear here. And once it's here today, there aren't a ton of solutions to actually recycle clothing that we're finished using. Clothing that is mixed fiber, the technology really does not yet exist and certainly is not at scale to make that, break that down and make it into fiber that could then actually make clothing again. So a circular economy, closed loop circular system for clothing recycling does not yet exist, is not yet accessible to consumers. So we really need to figure out how to make the most of what we already have, specifically what's already in our closets, right? And so we'll get into. Human behavior around consumption, I'm sure later on in this conversation. But what I've really been interested in doing is figuring out how, at a hyper-local level, can we build community around sustainable fashion by making it easier for people to exchange clothing with each other. So I organize kind of fun community events that are kind of more like a party than work, where people can bring the. Too many things that they might have bought this season, last season, that they're just not using, but which somebody else might have a great need for. And so if we can make it normative and easy and fun and convenient to exchange things locally, I see that as one of the most potentially impactful changes in behavior that I can champion now. And then going along with that, sorry, is just mending workshops to keep things that we have. That we have.
Juravich: Well, you wrote a piece for the documentary's website about duty of care. So you write in it that we need to take care of our clothes and hand them off to another person. So yeah, tell me more about that. I guess, what does it mean to take of your clothes?
Goldsand: To me, it also, it boils down to how much time we spend consuming clothing, right? So, you know, we have lunch with a friend and then we find ourselves at Madewell or Aritzia buying something we maybe don't need, right. But that's time, or we have a tough day and we maybe sit on our couch and scroll and purchase something. We're spending time soothing ourselves through consumption, but we spend time deciding what we're gonna. Purchase and have delivered to our home, then we deal with how much storage space we have, we move our things around every season, et cetera. Then when we're finished using something, I think we could probably spend more time getting it ready to enter someone else's hands. So, you know, could we spend a little bit of time removing the deodorant stain or the lipstick or makeup stain that's on something that we're just done using? Because that's probably gonna make it more likely that someone who sees it at an exchange wants to use it, or that someone whose shopping for it in a thrift store is gonna use it. The consumer really needs to think about their responsibility for that thing that they chose to buy kind of all the way through until it leaves their hands.
Juravich: And Tasha, talk to me about the greatest influence in how we dress. Is it the quality of clothes? Is it availability of clothes, like what influences what we pick?
Lewis: So I just looked at some research or data on this yesterday and trying to think about what drives us to buy clothing but also to not buy clothing as well. A big factor is price actually. It does have to do with styling and then also fit is a big determinant how something fits you. But a lot of it is we are driven by what we see, something esthetically pleasing, but also how much it costs. So that's always a big. Factor in buying something. I'm sure, as Lisa was talking about people scrolling, I was like, how much is that going to cost? But I'm one of the people that I just like to look at fashion. So I may not buy it, but it's an appreciation of well-made clothing or nice clothing or luxury clothing, but may not be able to afford it.
Juravich: But I can appreciate it. Well, since you teach in the Department of Human Sciences, you know, we were talking, you know when we were talking about this show, we're talking about a time whenever sewing was taught in school, in home economics class, I took a home economics, class I learned to sew, not only a button but a pillow, you know, but and people used to make their own I mean, how do we push people away from that? What happened?
Lewis: I think as we moved our manufacturing away from the country, it also became maybe less valuable as a skill to teach people to sew, because it maybe felt like it wasn't a career path anymore like it used to be. And so I think, in my opinion, that may have been what happened as we shifted more to the marketing and maybe the product development part of fashion, like we can design it, we can think about how to sell it, but we don't necessarily make it here anymore. And so it wasn't as much of a value around making it. I think there is a resurgence of interest in sewing and making that I see among younger generations that they wanna know how to make something or understand how something is constructed. And I think even once you know that, you know how take something apart and make it into something else, which can be very valuable as well. So I'm like you, I appreciate the craft of sewing and the idea of being able to make something with your own hands. And I just bought it. Another sewing machine recently. So I think that that's part of.
Juravich: My hobby now. This is All Sides on 89.7 NTR News. We're talking about the true cost of what we wear. We're taking with Lisa Goldsan, founder of Circular Thrift, and Tasha Lewis, an associate professor in the Ohio State Department of Human Sciences. But Tasha, there's that push toward careers in the trades. Everyone says we need more electricians and welders and mechanics, so why aren't we pushing sewing as like making a comeback as a career in the trade?
Lewis: Well, I would say I don't know, but sometimes it's because of the cost of labor, how much it costs to sew something here versus sewing it in a country that might have lower labor costs, so it may not be so financially viable. But I do think there's an opportunity to maybe think more of what can we make that's really high value. Maybe we need to make some more technology-enabled garments, some more high-tech ideas around clothing that are not necessarily what we've traditionally made in terms of clothing. And you can also use sewing as a skill in industrial settings. So sewing is not just sewing clothes, but sometimes you have to sew like a car seat cover. That's still a sewing skill. So not that it's, it's not entirely relatable to what we do in industrial setting. So I think sewing is a life skill. Yeah. So I like to go on the record for that. Yeah.
Juravich: Yeah, Lisa, you're nodding along. I'm sure with your idea of the circular economy, you wish more people made their clothes, right?
Goldsand: I do. Having this vivid memory, my mother bought me a sewing machine when I was 12 or so. And then she went to work. So I made myself a pair of clam diggers all by myself. And figuring that out on my own was very exciting. And I think we all benefit from doing things with our hands. I think there's a lot of positive impact on that kind of physical work. But I would just offer there are green shoots associated with demand for psoists in the U.S. One example is
Juravich: What does a green shoot mean? Yeah, you know.
Goldsand: Positive signs of change. So there's a business located in Ohio, in Bokdil, Ohio, called the Hocking Hills Garment Center that was opened by Betsy Franjola. And she opened a sew plant. And when she was starting to do it, people said, oh, nobody's going to want to learn to sew. And this little factory is busy all the time. And Betsy has a wait list for people who are part of her apprentice program. The other thing... That I think could be really interesting in central Ohio specifically is doing something creative with all of the dead stock that's located in distribution centers here. So we've talked about the fact that there are several very large fashion companies that are corporately located in Ohio, but pretty much every brand that has distribution. In the US, has stores, a store footprint in the U.S., has distribution here in central Ohio. And purchasing, buying the right things in the right color, in the the right style, in the region, in right distribution center is very, very difficult. And so as a result, we end up with roughly 20 to 30% of inventory that a buyer for a brand purchased, never making it to the... Customer just because it was the wrong something wrong size.
Juravich: Someone ordered the wrong color, yeah.
Goldsand: Yeah. And so I think that there is a great white space opportunity for, number one, creatives located in the U.S. To say, oh, here's a, I don't know, here is a land's end pant. Let me see what really cool thing I can make from that. Well, there might be dead stock, a thousand units of that pant. And then you actually could have an actual business where you're combining domestic labor and domestic creatives. And I think it could really exciting.
Juravich: And Professor Lewis, we've heard the term fast fashion a lot. I mean, can you tell me what fast fashion is and how it's impacting the industry or the environment?
Lewis: Sure, so Fast Fashion has been with us for about, I would say, maybe two decades if I do like a really generous timeline, but this is the idea of the supply chain of making clothing being greatly shortened. It used to take about maybe a year or like six months to get clothing designed, produced, manufactured and into a store. Fast Fashion is taking that timeline down to a month or less, so you're working with number of weeks so you get more inventory into your store. Closer to when people want to buy it, maybe when they're more interested in the trend. We're now in an era of what we call ultra-fast fashion, so even faster than that. Oh man. So it means that we're just, we're going through the resources faster, we're getting rid of it faster, because usually if you're making it faster it's not high quality, so it's now gonna last very long, and so then you're throwing it out faster, so we're giving a higher disposal rate. So it was started out as maybe a way to be more efficient with fashion, to really be closer to your suppliers, to make here. Supply chain more efficient, but I think we sort of overshot our goals with how fast could we be and maybe how fast shouldn't we be in terms of consumption.
Juravich: Yeah, I'm sure, Lisa, I am just guessing here, but you're not a fan of fast fashion.
Goldsand: Well, actually, I have maybe a different and slightly controversial view about what brands we might consider belong in that fast fashion category. I think too much is said about the difference in quality between a lower price point brand and a higher price point. I think that any company that has a monthly drop or a weekly drop, even if they make quality, even if they... Charge a higher average unit retail for their product kind of technically is fast fashion. And I also think that all companies, all brands that are serving their shareholders by continuing to increase profitability quarter on quarter, they're kind of stuck in a loop. So by definition, they need to sell more product or sell product at a higher, average unit of retail to comp the prior selling period. So that kind of puts all brands on a bit of a fast fashion loop.
Juravich: Everything's fast. Everything's faster now. Yeah. And Professor Lewis, just to end on with you, you know, there's skepticism about that. The fashion industry cares about the environment. Some people call it greenwashing to say you care about the environment, but your actions don't really fit that. Do you see that happening today?
Lewis: We see some of it. I think I would say I see some brands trying to make an earnest effort and some brands that are really, they do try to leverage. I talked to my students yesterday about vegan leather. I said I have a, I struggle with it because I know it's not plant-based but because it's not an animal you can call it that. And I feel like brands don't always know what to do. Like the map is not really there. Like what should we do? Should we focus on better fibers? Should we focus on being able to recycle? So I think we just don't have a comprehensive lens of, this is what you should be doing. So they're kind of coming up with their own approach to what they think is good, but it may not be the best for the environment overall. But there are some metrics that are emerging that I think will give better guidelines and maybe areas of focus for brands that they can start to address some real issues that are merging in the industry.
Juravich: We've been talking with Tasha Lewis, an associate professor in the Ohio State Department of Human Sciences. Thank you for joining us today. Thank you. And Lisa Goldsand is going to stay with us, the founder of Circular Thrift. And coming up, we're gonna talk about what's next for the fashion industry. That's when All Sides continues on 89.7 NPR News.
You're listening to All Sides, I'm your host Amy Juravich. We're weaving our way through the history, systems, and decisions that have resulted in the overabundance of clothing at thrift stores and in our landfills. And we're speaking with the Ohio historians, experts, and creatives behind the three-part documentary called "Tangled Threads." We're now gonna look at what comes next for the fashion industry and consumers. Still with us is Lisa Goldsand, founder of Circular Thrift, a nonprofit that offers community-centered circular fashion and textile waste. Solutions. Thanks again for being here, Lisa. Thank you so much. And joining our conversation now is Brett Langolf, executive producer and director of the docu-series, "Tangled Threads." Welcome to All Sides, Brett. Thanks. So, Brett, what was the impetus for making Tangled threads? Why did you decide to make a docu series? Well...
Brett Langolf: I love stories and I love to help uncover stories. That's what we do in the documentary space. And when I met Lisa, she started telling me about the circular economy and what we do with clothes. And I was literally sitting there thinking, I don't even know what I'm wearing right now. And the more I got into it, I love take things that have a purpose and make it into production and tell those stories. And the one thing we all have in common is we all wear clothes. It's like the one we all do. We probably brush our teeth and get dressed every day.
And so if people could understand what went into it and could make better informed decisions, we just want to inspire some action. And when I was surrounded by all the smartest people in the room, which have all been on this, you know, this segment today, I said, we've got to tell this story. So that's why I got behind it because I have no background in fashion whatsoever.
Juravich: Lisa, the documentary features interviews with the fashion brands Eileen Fisher and Patagonia. Why were those particular companies interviewed for the documentary?
Goldsand: Yeah, so if you start to look into brands that are in existence today, that have a significant footprint in the industry, you find a couple of brands that are doing some interesting things and then nothing, nothing, nothing, and then kind of everybody else that's sort of in the middle of the pack. And the interesting thing about Patagonia and Eileen Fischer is that they are not publicly held. So Eileen Fisher is privately held still. And Patagonia is essentially owned by a green bond. And so each of these organizations are a bit less encumbered, such that they can be more creative and take certain risks and shift their whole corporate culture toward a sustainability mission, if they so choose.
Juravich: Brett, in your opinion, what should the standard be for partnerships, sponsors, working with companies interested in attaching their name or brand to a documentary like "Tangled Threads?" How did you work with that?
Langolf: Yeah, definitely. Well, first I check with Lisa to make sure, but no, we do have a conversation as a group that understands because my background is actually advertising. So a lot of brands can advertise they do this in a great commercial, but you look at the business and say, well, that's 2% of what they actually do. So we spend a lot time discussing what brands should be featured, what brands should be discussed to make that they're living up to. To what they say. So the criteria is really a collective group of just looking into it and understanding history. And really some brands may have had a bad history, but they're looking to change things. And that's where we open the conversation.
Juravich: Well, the idea of Columbus being this fashion powerhouse, we have so many brands here. I mean, did you approach Victoria's Secret, Abercrombie and Fitch, all the ones that are headquartered here, to ask them questions, to say, what do you think of the fact that we can't recycle any of your stuff?
Langolf: We haven't yet, but as we're crafting these episodes and as we are letting the story unfold, one of the most important things is we knew what type of story we wanted to tell, but we let the story come to us. And it shapes every interview we have. Every time we go speak with someone. You know, we left Manhattan this summer after Eileen Fisher in Patagonia, and we came back and said, wow, we've learned a lot. Where do we take this next? And so we're continuing to figure out what brands we do and do not want to talk to. And there's probably some brands that do not want to talk to us.
Juravich: Well, your website says the goal of the film is to inform audiences, provide context, and inspire meaningful action across consumers, industry, and policy. So tell me about that action part.
Langolf: The action is just at the end of every episode, we want you to be able to take one thing away. There's gonna be a lot of information and we're surrounded by very smart historians and people within the fashion industry that you've heard from. But if I get done with an episode and I'm a 14 year old boy or a teenage girl, I go, do I really need that shirt? Do I, can this shirt be something different? Should I wear this 10 more times? We just want to have a slight tweak when you look in your closet every morning.
Juravich: Lisa, with so many thrift stores and resell platforms having an overabundance of stock, I mean, they just have too many clothes, they can't even fit them in the store. How do shops determine what items they take and then what happens to the overstock in a thrift store?
Goldsand: Yeah I think it's increasingly challenging for thrift stores to figure that out, to determine how they engage with their consumers. Should they be discerning and say to their consumers, don't bring us this, that, and that, and then risk the consumer not bringing them anything? That's a challenge that I know Goodwill struggles with. They're open arms, and they're going to figure out what to do with what they don't deem to have resale value. I think that the big challenge that we're gonna need to address as a country is the bottom of the pyramid. So a thrift store's gonna take in whatever you drop off, whatever's been in the back of your car for four months, and they're gonna figure out what they can sell in that location where you dropped it off, what they might hold because it's seasonal and sell at a later time, maybe even in a different location. But the challenge that thrift stores are needing to face What about stuff that's truly not saleable? Like, do you want to go to a thrift store and buy a Turkey Trot T-shirt from 2021? You know, probably not, right? So that's where I think thrift stores are trying to figure out what to do because the thrift-store infrastructure across the country probably will be a part of the solution as technology does scale so that that stuff it. That turkey trot t-shirt does become feedstock for downcycling into industrial insulation or some other product.
Juravich: This is All Sides on 89.7 NPR News. We're talking about what comes next with the fashion industry. We're taking with Lisa Goldsan, founder of Circular Thrift, and Brett Langolf, executive director and producer of the docu-series "Tangled Threads." So Brett, what's been the most surprising thing you learned about clothing production making this documentary?
Langolf: I learn something every day, so I'm in all the interviews. And it's funny because my job is to translate what this is to all audiences. So I get to play the dumbest guy in the room every time we do an interview, it's fantastic. And most of the interviews we do, I raise my hand and I have follow-up questions and I'm the one asking, but the answers are fascinating. I found out that we eat a credit card a week worth of plastic due to how we wash our clothing, so. Huh? Yeah, exactly, exactly. So yeah, it's because of the plastics that go into the clothing and the materials and the water, we ended up ingesting the equivalent of a credit card a week.
Juravich: Oh, that's fun.
Langolf: Yeah, that's super fun. Tasha Lewis handled it in her first interview that she did. But I've learned so much just looking from the outside in. And it's been a fascinating process. And I'm really excited to help translate that into a film to audiences so they can take their own action.
Juravich: Lisa, I saw an interesting piece that you wrote. I think I saw it on the documentary's website that you call it the spirit wear trap. And you kind of mentioned it with the Turkey Trot t-shirt that you mentioned. So schools create a shirt or a hoodie for everything. I mean, tell me about that problem with single event apparel.
Goldsand: Yeah Single event apparel just needs to go away. So unless you're, I think I wrote about this a couple of years ago, unless you are Taylor Swift or NASA, you probably shouldn't be making a T-shirt. I don't think that the people who got their braces want, really want a T shirt with the name of the company that gave them their braces to wear around. I think we need to think about as we make things, what is the utility of this item? And so.
Juravich: But schools use them for, like, community. Everyone wears the same shirt for the event. The schools use it for fundraisers. Yeah.
Goldsand: I think schools have a really great opportunity. They just need to implement a different strategy when they develop and source products. So I think there's an opportunity for schools to make money through spirit wear exchanges. I think, there's also an opportunity for schools to follow a different sourcing structure. So for example, do you really need to put the year on something? There can be a great, you know, I'm from, I live in Bexley, Ohio, sweatshirt that can go through. Five different owners, but let's keep maybe the person's name and the year off it, and then it has tremendous increased utility.
Juravich: And I also wanted to ask about recycling, because you mentioned a couple of times that we haven't figured out how to recycle most things. And with all the clothing that we have and this overabundance and everything we've been talking about, how have we not figured it out? Lisa, can you talk about that? So...
Goldsand: So, so far, the technology that is emerging is pretty good at addressing what's referred to as single substrate clothing. So something that's 100% wool, 100% polyester, 100% cotton. The technology to recycle through either a mechanical or a chemical process, clothing that is a blend is really far from being at scale. So Clothing that's a blend of fibers probably isn't gonna end up as a fiber that makes new clothing again anytime soon. And so, and it's expensive and it is resource intensive to take even those single substrate items and put them through a true recycling process.
Juravich: I just want to think that you can take a piece of clothing and make it into another piece of clothing. It just seems like it should be possible.
Goldsand: I think that you will be able to eventually. I mean, I actually wonder if you think about fast fashion, right, we talked about fast-fashion this whole episode. I'm curious as to whether five, 10 years down the road, if you wanna wear a really specific outfit that's fashion, right, to a specific event, are you gonna 3D print it? And it's gonna be all synthetic and then you're just gonna go recycle it at the end, truly recycle it back into something else that's plastic at the ends. But this technology's just not quite there for us too. Be careless with what we consume to think that it has another place to go at the end.
Juravich: Brett, I know that people listening probably want to watch this, but "Tangled Threads" is still in production. Tell me about where you are in the production process and when people will be able to see it.
Langolf: Yes. So we are probably halfway through the principal filming. We've got a big wave coming up. What we just talked about recycling reuse centers and digging into that. So really what we're driving towards is in December we're going to have a fundraising event to help support the film and we're going to premiere a rough cut of episode one. So a lot of people go to holiday parties. Hopefully they'll come. See what we're up to. Really the goal is early spring. I have a premiere at the Drexel Theater in Bexley, Ohio and then throughout the city and we're just going to start rolling out the episodes from there.
Juravich: Yeah, Lisa, what are you looking forward to about this, the end of the production process and getting this out there?
Goldsand: Well, I'm really looking forward to getting the product in front of people because, and I wanna say one thing about Brett before we close. Brett is, he doesn't look, I know none of your listeners can see him, but this guy doesn't like he's the tremendously purpose-driven content creator that he actually is. So Brett is very humbly and quietly trying to change the world by making content that is positive, that inspires action. There's the compliment. It came around. He knew. He knew it was coming. You're changing the world. I didn't know where she was going with this. And one of the things that we've talked a lot about behind the scenes is this is hard. This is a complicated ecosystem. What you're not going to see from this project is finger pointing or any salacious rumor spreading about one brand or one entity or another, we want people to be educated so that they can make different decisions about their own relationship with consumption. And we think that that is what is gonna drive change.
Langolf: And I think if I could add one thing to that, the one thing you're also not gonna see is a solution in this film because there isn't a solution yet, but there are small micro solutions every time and that's why we're trying to inspire the action to make these little changes. So we're really just trying to drive it forward and I'm really excited to get it out there because I've learned so much through this process that I'm excited to share it with audiences.
Juravich: Yeah, I mean, just in this short 55 minutes, I am now pondering what I'm wearing and everything in my closet and wondering how many times I've worn it. I kind of want to like start counting or something.
Langolf: Well, get ready for the premiere. You'll be invited, so think about what you're going to wear. I'll think about I'm going to need to get something from Patagonia.
Juravich: You've been speaking, or we have been speaking with Lisa Goldsand, founder of Circular Thrift. Thanks for being here, Lisa. Thank you so much. And Brett Langolf, executive producer and director of the docu-series "Tangled Threads." Brett, thanks for being her. Thanks for having us. And you have been listening to All Sides on 89.7 NPR News. I'm Amy Juravich.