© 2024 WOSU Public Media
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

HHS Inspector General Finds Serious Flaws In 20% Of U.S. Hospice Programs

From 2012 through 2016, federal health inspectors cited 87% of U.S. hospices for deficiencies. And 20% had lapses serious enough to endanger patients, according to two new reports from the HHS Inspector General's Office.
Getty Images
From 2012 through 2016, federal health inspectors cited 87% of U.S. hospices for deficiencies. And 20% had lapses serious enough to endanger patients, according to two new reports from the HHS Inspector General's Office.

We all hope for some peace and comfort at the end of life. Hospices are designed to make that possible, relieving pain and providing emotional and spiritual support. But two new government studies released Tuesday morning find that the vast majority of hospices have sometimes failed to do that.

And there's no easy way for consumers to distinguish the good hospices from the bad.

The reports are the government's first to look at hospice deficiencies nationwide. The Office of the Inspector General in the Department of Health and Human Services found that from 2012 through 2016, health inspectors cited 87% of hospices for deficiencies. And 20% of hospices had lapses serious enough to endanger patients.

Deputy Regional Inspector General Nancy Harrison cites the case of a patient who had untreated bed sores, or pressure ulcers, on both heels.

"These ulcers rapidly worsened," says Harrison. "The patient developed gangrene and needed a leg amputation."

In the dry terminology of government reports, this is called "poor care planning." And having plans of care developed in conjunction with the patient and the patient's family, Harrison says, is a fundamental requirement of hospice.

"So when we discover that hospices are not doing them, there is reason for concern," she says.

For example, there's the case ofKaren Bishop Collings and her 85-year-old dad, Dean Bishop. Though Bishop had chronic lung disease, he'd been doing OK and living independently. Then, last winter, he was hospitalized with pneumonia. When he was transferred to a residential care facility to recuperate, he began receiving hospice services. That was a surprise to his daughter.

"We only agreed to pre-assessment of his conditions, to even see if he qualified for hospice or palliative care," she says.

Collings has shared some of her father's medical records with NPR, and they verify her recollection. The hospice never held a meeting with Bishop or the family to establish a care plan. So Collings was shocked when hospice workers gave her father two new medications: morphine and the anti-anxiety drug Ativan.

"We knew something distressing had happened," she says. "His whole physicality and mental capacity was completely altered."

Dean Bishop died a couple of days later.

If this hospice had previously been cited for deficiencies, Collings would have had a hard time finding out. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, or CMS, doesn't make that information available on Hospice Compare, its website for consumers, even though the agency has the authority to post at least some of that data.

"We live in a time when we don't even think about booking a hotel without checking its ratings and reviews," says Harrison. "Why do we demand less for hospices?"

The reports also highlight that the options CMS has for disciplining hospices are few. The agency can drop substandard hospices from the Medicare program altogether. But it lacks the legal authority to assess fines. It would take an act of Congress to give CMS that power.

In response to the Inspector General's Office reports, CMS issued a written statement that the agency "has zero tolerance for abuse and mistreatment of any patient." The statement also says that the agency has added consumer feedback to the Hospice Compare website. Nancy Harrison thinks that's not enough.

"There are a lot of great hospices out there," Harrison says. "There are a lot of highly skilled, committed professionals who are dedicated to helping others leave this life in comfort and with dignity — and the public should know about them."

The amount of money that Medicare spends on hospice services has roughly doubled since 2006. But Harrison says this isn't just a matter of taxpayer dollars.

You're only going to die once, she says. It's important that things go right.

Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

Corrected: July 9, 2019 at 12:00 AM EDT
In previous audio and Web versions of this story, we misidentified the deputy regional inspector general. She is Nancy Harrison, not Katherine Harris.
Ina Jaffe is a veteran NPR correspondent covering the aging of America. Her stories on Morning Edition and All Things Considered have focused on older adults' involvement in politics and elections, dating and divorce, work and retirement, fashion and sports, as well as issues affecting long term care and end of life choices. In 2015, she was named one of the nation's top "Influencers in Aging" by PBS publication Next Avenue, which wrote "Jaffe has reinvented reporting on aging."