© 2026 WOSU Public Media
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations
Crime and Public Safety

True crime series 'Unsolved Mysteries' revived with new host, puts spotlight on Columbus case

"Unsolved Mysteries" Host Jordan Murphy discussing the case of Joey LaBute.
Facebook/Unsolved Mysteries
"Unsolved Mysteries" Host Jordan Murphy discussing the case of Joey LaBute.

Nearly 40 years after it first debuted on network television, the next generation of "Unsolved Mysteries" can now be seen on YouTube with new cases released each week to the faithful followers of the classic true crime series.

Jordan Murphy, the show’s new host, joined WOSU Morning Edition Host Stu Osborne to discuss a local case that was featured on the new iteration and his connection to "Unsolved Mysteries" that dates back more than three decades.

Jordan Murphy: It's an interesting story because I grew up in the northern California area, San Francisco Bay area, and I was trying to become an actor, auditioning, doing what I could. And I got an audition for this show called "Unsolved Mysteries." Never heard of it before, really, you know what I mean? It was young to me and I auditioned for it. I booked the job. I ended up becoming a reenactor on an episode of "Unsolved Mysteries" in 1992. That's how I got my SAG card. That's kind of like the back story to it, but full circle. What ended up happening was five, six months ago, I got an email from my manager saying you have an audition to host a show called "Unsolved Mysteries," and I thought "Unsolved Mysteries," THE "Unsolved Mysteries?" Is that still on? I love the full circle element of it. So I put myself on tape, sent it in, they brought me back again (and) we had multiple meetings. Fortunately, it went my way.

Stu Osborne: One of the cases you featured is actually from the Columbus area (about a man named) Joey LaBute. In 2016, he went missing while he was out with friends, (and was later) found dead in the Scioto River. What did you learn when talking to police and those close to him when you were doing this case?

Jordan Murphy: Well, I think what we learned is what you'll find in the actual podcast itself. There's only so much we can divulge because there's only so much they divulged to us, obviously, because it's obviously somewhat of an ongoing case still, but there wasn't a lot to go on. He disappeared. He left a very cryptic text that nobody to this day has been able to decipher, to understand who it was.

There's a lot of theories. His father, Joey Sr., is still very much involved. In fact, actually, if you go to the podcast comments, he's very involved in the communication with the actual audience members about theories that they're presenting. And this is part of what I think is so important about this show, is this is 10 years ago, you know what? People's memories. It's amazing. I think people's memories are still there in the cloud, if you will, if you draw it down and we bring these ideas back to people, there was actually a conference going on at the, would you call it, the Convention Center there nearby. So a lot of extra people were in the area at that time. So there were theories about could it have been somebody who wasn't from the area, but it also means there's a lot of extra people. Around at that time, which means a lot of extra eyeballs, which means a ton of extra memories. So perhaps that could lend to some extra evidence, theories, feedback from people.

Stu Osborne: Now, during that segment, you mentioned another case that's been kind of in the Columbus lore for even longer, almost 20 years now. Brian Shaffer kind of under similar circumstances. (He) went to a bar, (was) seen on TV going up the escalator (and) disappeared. Do you guys have any plans to do an episode on Brian Shaffer, or was it just kind of like a brief mention since the case was so parallel?

Jordan Murphy: Really it was, and you'll see in the episode itself, the detective speaks to the similarities. We will not be pursuing it any further right this moment. It was really just to kind of identify the fact that there seemed to be some similarities, but there were only a few.

Stu Osborne: Now, what has reaction been so far? I mean, you're only five or six episodes in. What's reaction from the fan base been?

Jordan Murphy: Over five episodes, I believe we've had over a million views if you spread them out over the episodes themselves. So eyeballs are on, so that's positive. We want people watching. The comments are what really blows me away. The comments, the engagement by our audience is really, really powerful. They really, really want to provide genuine feedback. Theories, concepts, and we want those. Now, here's the thing. We want that dialogue. We will be dialoguing. I will be dialoguing. I will be generating videos that hopefully address some of the patterned or repeated conversations that happen within the audience. Put it in the comments, get a conversation going, but if there's something where somebody really remembers something or has an actual piece of evidence that they can provide for investigators to look closer at. Please go to unsolved.com. That's really the best route.

You can follow the show and Jordan Murphy on social media:
Unsolved Mysteries YouTube
Unsolved Mysteries Instagram
Jordan Murphy Instagram

Tags
Crime and Public Safety true crimeunsolved crimesJoey Labute
Related Content