© 2026 WOSU Public Media
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations
Health, Science & Environment

Health workers receiving more threats since COVID-19 outbreak, study says

Ohio State employee Stacey Boyer, left, receives a Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine from Kelli Barnes Monday, Dec. 14, 2020, in Columbus, Ohio.
Jay LaPrete
/
Associated Press
The Ohio Study found that health department leaders reported working 15 hours a day sometimes, seven days a week during the pandemic to try to keep people from dying from COVID and keep hospitals from being overwhelmed.

A new Ohio State University study finds public health officials are experiencing more threats of physical harm which spread during the start of the COVID-19 pandemic.

It's leading to many health workers taking early retirement or leaving the field of public health altogether.

WOSU’s Debbie Holmes spoke with Marian Moser Jones, the lead author of the study and an associate professor of health services management and policy at Ohio State's College of Public Health.

Debbie Holmes: What's the environment like?

Marian Moser Jones: Well, Debbie, the environment has gotten worse since 2020. We interviewed about 109 local and state health department leaders from cities and towns and rural areas across Ohio and 17 other states. And we found that health department leaders reported working sometimes 15 hours a day, seven days a week during the pandemic to try to keep people from dying of COVID and keep the hospitals from being overwhelmed. And yet, 76% of the people we interviewed reported that they experienced threats, harassment or intimidation.

Debbie Holmes: You said there were 109 leaders. Were some of them from OSU then?

Marian Moser Jones: No, they were from health departments. Every state has a health department, state health department and then you have county and city health departments, so none of them were academics.

Debbie Holmes: All right, so tell us about the study and how you conducted this.

Marian Moser Jones: We reached out to people who had served as health commissioners and health department directors across the country. We got their names from the professional organizations that they belonged to. And we conducted these in-depth interviews with the leaders and former leaders. And we learned all about their experiences during COVID, the good, the bad, the ugly.

Debbie Holmes: Why is public health threatening to people?

Marian Moser Jones: Well, that's a good question. I think normally it's not. Normally, public health operates in the background. It's the people who go to make sure to inspect restaurants, to make sure you don't get salmonella from your restaurant. People who are inspecting water sources to make sure that our water isn't contaminated or issuing a boil water ordinance. During the pandemic, there were actions taken to, as I say, protect the public, also keep our hospitals from being overwhelmed, including mask mandates, including vaccine rollouts, including closures of businesses and schools that limited people's autonomy and individual liberty in ways that are actually consistent with what's been done in the past, but most of this has not been done in our lifetimes. And so, a lot of people said, 'whoa, well, I, you know, why is public health telling me I can't go and do this'? And in fact, in many places, including Ohio, I mean, the governor was issuing these orders. It wasn't actually the health department. But people saw public health as a threat to their individual freedom.

Debbie Holmes: Now, why do you think this is still happening?

Marian Moser Jones: Well, I think right now the threats have actually subsided, but the biggest form of threat to public health right now is really the claw backs and cutbacks of federal funding for state and local public health. And this means workforce cutbacks. And people were so burned out from the pandemic. That burnout has become a really persistent issue in local and state health departments.

Debbie Holmes: Now your research team has identified some successful strategies public health leaders have used. Can you talk about those?

Marian Moser Jones: I just want to emphasize that we're not talking about just peaceful protest, people exercising their constitutionally protected right to protest a decision they don't agree with. But there were times when people were doing that, say protesting outside the health department, and health leaders sometimes would go outside, talk to protesters, engage them, give them a cup of coffee. Or even in smaller towns and areas where they knew the people who were really beyond the, behind the opposition, reach out to them, have dialogue, etc.

But there were other cases where they really weren't able to do that because there were people who were actually threatening them, publishing their names in schools and athletic schedules of their children, showing up at their homes and blocking their driveways armed, sending graphic and demeaning sexual comments, even rape threats to women health officials, and in the case of health officials who belong to identifiable ethnic minorities, using slurs against them. In that case, what you need is protection from your local police or sheriff's department. In many cases, that was when the sheriffs and the police did show up to protect the health officials. In some cases, in some states, unfortunately, they didn't and the health leaders had to move.

Tags
Health, Science & Environment public healthCOVID-19 pandemic
Debbie Holmes has worked at WOSU News since 2009. She has hosted All Things Considered, since May 2021. Prior to that she was the host of Morning Edition and a reporter.
Related Content